Coalition for an
Underground Alternative

 

E-Mail: info@burytheline.com
© Copyright 2009

 

 

 

 

 

Latest News

 

17,000 Without Power Following Winter Storm
Kansas City Airport Closed Due to Snow Storm
FoxNews.com -- Associated Press
March 28, 2009
 
Kansas City, Mo. -- A storm has buried parts of Kansas in more than two feet of snow and knocked out power to at least 17,000 homes and businesses.
 
Some areas are dealing with freezing rain that has coated power lines and trees with ice up to an inch thick. The Kansas Adjutant General's Office said 17,000 customers are without power.
 
To read the complete story, click here.
 
CUA COST ESTIMATE
Two of CUA's experts inlcude James B. Simmonds and Christopher L. DeMarco. They have included in their testimony cost estimates for underground and overhead transmission lines. These costs are many times LESS than what ATC has quoted for undergrounding, and in many cases, it is LOWER than what ATC has quoted to build the overhead lines. ATC has quoted that the 345 KV line would run between 32 and 47 miles and could cost between $214 and $244 million, depending on the route.
 
Simmonds has spent his entire 40-year career involved in the analysis and estimation of the costs for installation of underground transmission systems in the United States and abroad. Simmonds has performed hundreds of cost estimates for various underground transmission projects. The projects involved 69 kV transmission lines to 345 kV transmission lines.
 
DeMarco is employed by the University of Wisconsin-Madison as a Professor and faculty member in the Deparment of Electrical and Computer Engineering. He has a Ph.D. and Masters of Science degrees from the Department of Electrical Engineeringa nd Computer Sciences at the University of California - Berkeley, and a Bachelor of Science degree in Electrical Engineering and Computer Science from teh Massachusetts Institute of Technology. In addition to his work with the UW, DeMarco has served as a consultant advising the Bonneville Power Administration (BPA) in the area of power system voltage stability, under a contract entitled "Response-Based Voltage Stability Controls: Industry Expert Panel Services."
 
UNDERGROUND TRANSMISSION LINE
138 kV HPGF Double Circuit - (complete cost estimate)
Total cost per two mile segment - $12,027,400
Average cost per mile -- $6,013,700
Cost for 17 miles -- $106,250,000 - $110,500,000
 
230 kV HPFF Double Circuit (complete cost estimate)
Total cost per two mile segment - $13,067,800
Average cost per mile -- $6,533,900
Cost for 17 miles -- $114,750,000 - $123,250,000
 
230 kV HPFF Single Circuit (complete cost estimate)
Total cost per two mile segment - $7,257,400
Average cost per mile - $3,628,700
Cost for 17 miles - $59,5000,000 - $68,000,000
 
345 kV XLPE Cable Double Circuit (complete cost estimate)
Total cost per two mile segment - $16,630,000
Average cost per mile -- $8,315,000
Cost for 25 miles -- $212,500,000 - $225,000,000
 
345 kV XLPE Cable Single Circuit (complete cost estimate)
Total cost per two mile segment -- $11,867,500
Average cost per mile -- $5,933,750
Cost for 25 miles -- $162,500,000 - $175,000,000
 
345 kV HPFF Double Circuit (complete cost estimate)
Total cost per two mile segment -- $16,100,000
Average cost per mile -- $8,050,000
Cost for 17 miles -- $136,000,000 - $153,000,000
 
345 kV HPFF Single Circuit (complete cost estimate)
Total cost per two mile segment -- $9,151,450
Average cost per mile -- $4,575,725
Cost for 17 miles -- $85,000,000 - $93,500,000
 
OTHER USEFUL LINKS:
 
Public can watch hearings online
A live video feed of the public hearings will be broadcast via the Internet and can be accessed by visiting the PSC Web site, or click here for the direct link.
 
To read the entire Cap Times article on the public hearings, click here.
 
Public Hearings Set for March 24 & 25
 
Notice was given that the PSC will hold hearings in this Class 1 contested case March 24, 25, and March 31 - April 3, 2009.
 
Comments from members of the public and others who are not parties will be received on March 24 and 25, 2009, at 1 p.m. and 6 p.m. in the Amnicon Falls Hearing Room at 610 North Whitney Way, Madison, Wis.
 
Click here to read the entire release.
 
Middleton Contributes $20,000 to cause
 
Click here to read entire article from the Middleton Times Tribune.
 
Update: Public hearings set on power-line proposal
Wisconsin State Journal - State Journal staff
Feb. 20, 2009
 

A final environmental impact statement has been issued and public hearings are scheduled next month in Madison on the proposed high-voltage electricity transmission line between Rockdale and Middleton in Dane County.

 

The 345-kilovolt line proposed by American Transmission Co. would run between 32 and 47 miles and could cost between $214 million and $244 million, depending on the route. The cost would be higher if portions of the line are built underground.

 

The EIS, issued this week by the state Public Service Commission and the Department of Natural Resources, examines four proposed routes for the line in terms of their environmental and social impact.

 
To read the complete article, click here.

 

 

Consultant hired to reconsider need for new transmission line

The Capital Times - Mike Ivey

Feb. 11, 2009

 

Will the combination of a deep economic slowdown, coupled with improvements in energy efficiency, preclude the need for a new $250 million high-voltage electric transmission line across Dane County?

 

It's a question some are asking as more factories close at the same time President Obama is calling for a greening of the nation's century-old electric system.

 

Last week, the Madison City Council approved hiring a consultant to study the economics of a new 345-kilovolt transmission line and to determine whether it is warranted. The city previously hired a consultant to study putting the line underground or somewhere other than along the Beltline highway as proposed.

 

Click here to read more.

Surprise Drop in Power Use Delivers Jolt to Utilities
The Wall Street Journal - Business, Rebecca Smith
Nov. 21, 2008
 

An unexpected drop in U.S. electricity consumption has utility companies worried that the trend isn't a byproduct of the economic downturn, and could reflect a permanent shift in consumption that will require sweeping change in their industry.

Numbers are trickling in from several large utilities that show shrinking power use by households and businesses in pockets across the country. Utilities have long counted on sales growth of 1% to 2% annually in the U.S., and they created complex operating and expansion plans to meet the needs of a growing population.

"We're in a period where growth is going to be challenged," says Jim Rogers, chief executive of Duke EnergyCorp. in Charlotte, N.C.

 

Read more.

 

PSC Seeks Public Comment on Draft Environmental Impact
Statement for Rockdale to West Middleton Transmission Line.

Nov. 12, 2008

 

The Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (PSC) has prepared a draft

Environmental Impact Statement (EIS) for a proposed 345 Kilovolt (kV) transmission line from

Rockdale to West Middleton and is seeking public input. To read the complete release, click here.

 

Copies of the draft EIS are available upon request by calling (800) 358-9246 or contact Christine Swailes by email at christine.swailes@psc.state.wi.us. It is available in either electronic (CD), *.PDF format or paper.

 

To review the report, it may be accessed at the PSC’s website at http://psc.wi.gov. To view the documents, click on the Electronic Regulatory Filing System (ERF) and enter docket number 137-CE-147.

 

On the Agenda: Burying ATC's power lines.

Isthmus, Vikki Kratz

 

Commission on the Environment
Monday, July 21, 2008 at 4:45 p.m.
Room 108, City-County Building

 

American Transmission Company’s application to build a 345-kilovolt power line in Dane County was recently deemed complete by the state Public Service Commission. The city of Madison would prefer that this massive power line not be constructed along the Beltline or, if it is, that it be buried. The city says the state Department of Transportation has “serious concerns” about the safety of having 120-foot towers on the Beltline. The commission will discuss a resolution urging the PSC to force ATC to bury the line. Good luck with that: The company says burying the line is too expensive -- and the PSC has never said “no” to ATC.

 

In other action, the commission will consider Ald. Michael Schumacher’s proposal to lower lake levels. Schumacher wants the Department of Natural Resources to agree to lower water levels on Lakes Monona and Mendota to avert potential flooding. The commission will also decide whether to pursue regulation of plastic water bottles and plastic bags.

 

ATC Application Complete For Power Line.
The clock has started ticking on American Transmission Company's proposal to build a 345-kilovolt transmission line across Dane County. The Public Service Commission has deemed the 2,000-page application as complete, and will start the formal process leading to approval or denial, a process that could take up to a year. To read The Capital Times article, click here.

 

Council ojects to above-ground power line along Beltline.
Madison's City Council voted August 5 to send a strong message about a potential power line that would run through Dane County along the Beltline. To read The Capital Times article, click here. To view the resolution passed by the City of Madison, click here.

 

 

The PSC declared the ATC application incomplete for the second time.

The ATC application was deemed incomplete for a second time in May 2008. For the article in the Capital Times, click here.  The original application was filed on October 16, 2007. The PSC declared that incomplete on November 15, 2007. The PSC has one year to rule on the application from the day it is determined complete.

 

PSC to Hold Public Outreach Meetings on ATC’s Proposed

Rockdale to West Middleton Transmission Line.

Jan. 29, 2008

 

The Public Service Commission of Wisconsin (PSC) will hold public outreach

meetings in the Madison, Fitchburg and Stoughton areas regarding an application from American

Transmission Company (ATC) to build between 32 and 55 miles of new transmission line and

related facilities in Dane County. Click here to read more.

 

Why won't ATC bury the lines?
Critics say there's no good reason they can't be out of sight.
Isthmus, Vikki Kratz on Jan 25, 2007

A rendering of the how the lines along the Beltline might look.
 
A rendering of the how the lines along the Beltline might look.

It's been done in Chicago, Boston, San Diego and San Francisco. The state of Connecticut passed a law requiring it whenever possible. And it's commonplace in Europe, Asia, Australia and Canada.

 

Burying transmission lines — even at voltages as high as 500 kilovolts — is an industry trend worldwide.

 

To read more, click here.

 

Dane County, City of Madison ask PSC for Independent Transmission Line Study.

Feb. 22, 2007 

 

Dane County and the City of Madison are filing with the Public Service Commission of Wisconsin a joint request for an independent study on the need for transmission line projects in the County.

The joint filing follows the November 7 election when Dane County voters approved a referendum seeking for an independent study to determine the energy needs of the area. The vote was about 75 percent (152,741) to 25 percent (48,495). 

 

To read more, click here.